UPDATE: Why NO Answers in the Martha Nolan Investigation, 5 Months After Her Unexplained Death on a Montauk Yacht

33-year-old Martha Nolan was found dead just after midnight on a boat in Montauk’s exclusive yacht club in early August. Police have not given any updates on her mysterious death after saying they were awaiting results from her autopsy and toxicology reports. The only witness to it all was a 60-year-old businessman, seen naked and upset running down the dock looking for help, and recent comments from his attorney have only made the story more bizarre and confusing. From the D4vd investigation, to the deaths of Martha Nolan and Anna Kepner, Amy and T.J. will spend this week going over some of the mysterious cases that plagued the headlines in 2025, to see where they are headed in the new year.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.