The Rise of Niche Podcasts: Why Smaller Can Be Stronger – PCI 464

Big audiences get the spotlight — but passionate, niche communities are where podcast success quietly thrives. In this episode of Podcast Insider, we dive into why smaller-focused shows are often more engaged, more loyal, and more profitable than broad, mass-appeal podcasts.

Whether your show is about vintage guitars, homeschooling twins, paranormal tourism, or the science of sleep — the beauty of podcasting is that there’s a niche for everything. We’ll explore how creators can grow strategically by going narrower, not broader. Today's Hosts: Mike Dell & MacKenzie Bennett Why Niches Drive Stronger Communities When listeners feel like the show gets them, they become true fans.

A niche focus leads to:

More qualified listeners Deeper engagement and retention Better audience feedback and participation Fewer competitors in your space

💡 Blubrry helps: Our analytics tools show exactly which topics and episodes resonate most — so you can double down on content your niche loves. Monetizing Small But Mighty Audiences You don’t need millions of listeners to earn real revenue.

Smart monetization strategies include:

Affiliate products relevant to your niche Community memberships or fan-supported models Partnerships with small brands who serve your audience Premium content for true fans

The goal? High-value conversations with a clearly defined audience.

💡 Blubrry helps: With Podcasting 2.0 features like Value4Value and subscriptions (via compatible integrations), monetizing loyal listeners is easier than ever. Marketing a Niche Podcast: Go Where They Are Instead of trying to reach everyone, reach your people.

Try:

Joining and participating in niche online communities Creating shareable micro-clips or visuals tailored to your topic Collaborating with aligned podcasts in your niche Optimizing episode titles for specific search intent

Small ponds = easier to become the big fish.

💡 Blubrry helps: Use Quicklinks to give new listeners a simple way to subscribe everywhere your show is available. Listener Takeaway If your show feels “too small,” that might be your superpower. When you speak directly to a specific group, your podcast becomes indispensable — and that’s what leads to lasting growth.

The best place for all Blubrry support is our ticket system. A ticket gives the whole team access vs. direct emails and calls. General podcasting discussion and more can be shared on the Blubrry Podcasting Facebook group.

Fill out our listener survey at surveys.blubrry.com/podcastinsider

Hosting customers can schedule a one-on-one call for a tech checkup with Mike (mike@blubrry.com).