Is that new song you like AI? Here’s how you can tell

The robots have arrived, and they're making protest songs about boots on the ground. When an AI band called The Velvet Sundown fooled over a million Spotify listeners with their psychedelic folk anthems, it raised an unsettling question: have the machines gotten so good we can no longer hear the difference? Charlie puts Nate to the test with a game of "AI or Human?" featuring Wu-Tang deepfakes, phantom instruments, and songs that sound like Dire Straits and Tom Petty had a baby. Along the way, they uncover the five telltale signs that expose artificial music, from juvenile rhyming patterns to voices that shapeshift between tracks. But here's the terrifying part: just six months ago, AI music was unlistenable chaos. Now it's disturbingly competent. And it's only getting better.

Songs Discussed

The Velvet Sundown - "Dust on the Wind"

Post Malone - "Chemical"

Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young - "Ohio"

The Velvet Sundown - "Freedom Song"

Kansas - "Dust in the Wind"

The Animals - "House of the Rising Sun"

Creedence Clearwater Revival - "Have You Ever Seen the Rain?"

The Velvet Sundown - "Where War Remains"

Pink Floyd - "Wish You Were Here"

The Velvet Sundown - "Ash and Velvet"

Buffalo Springfield - "For What It's Worth"

The Velvet Sundown - "For the Ones We Couldn't Keep"

The Velvet Sundown - "Mirrors in the Smoke"

Pink Floyd - "Breathe"

The Velvet Sundown - "Rebel Shout"

The Velvet Sundown - "Smoke in Silence"

The Velvet Sundown - "Marching Shadows"

The Velvet Sundown - "As the Silence Falls"

The Velvet Sundown - "How Did This Go Wrong?"

Hip Hop Intelligence - "Bar Fight" (AI Wu-Tang)

Hip Hop Intelligence - "Party with Me" (AI Eminem)

Temple of the Acid Fist Records - "Woman Gone Blues" (AI)

"Echoes of Twilight" (AI student example)

The Velvet Underground - "Sweet Jane"

"Whispers of Chaos" (Charlie's AI generation)

Mungo Jerry - "In the Summertime"

Almost Vinyl - "Phil Wildo's Door to Door Dildos" (AI)

Joey Two Legs - "I Shouldn't Have Done That" (hybrid)

Bill Evans AI track (untitled, by Nobody in the Computer)

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices